7

(This is not about restricting client access, for which ext3 permissions do the trick)

I'd like to encrypt the data on my NAS drive (Buffalo LinkStation Pro with SSH access enabled, if that matters) in a user-friendly way. Currently, a truecrypt container has to be manually mounted via SSH and also unmounted again (unless you solve my timeout question). Using a passwordless (but EFS encrypted) SSH key this is reduced to two PuTTY desktop shortcuts and entering the truecrypt password (until simplified further) for mounting.

However, the ideal solution would be transparent. I first thought about trying to somehow have the share allow for EFS encryption, but that would probably involve more work and EFS for multiple users without an Active Directory server seems to be troublesome.

But now my idea is an automated mount of e.g. an EncFS encrypted directory triggered automatically by a samba access from authorized users (using Windows clients). How can that be achieved? (Bonus points for displaying a honeypot share for unauthorized users...)

Community
  • 1
Tobias Kienzler
  • 9,184
  • 13
  • 65
  • 106
  • I still don't understand who has the encryption credentials in the scenario: are they provided by the user when mounting? Does it have to be a password, or can it be a key file (which itself might be password-protected) on the client or the server (which)? – Gilles 'SO- stop being evil' Oct 11 '12 at 09:48
  • @Gilles In this scenario, the Windows username/password transmitted to samba would also be used as encryption credentials (Ideally in such way that multiple users can mount the same volume with different credentials). – Tobias Kienzler Oct 11 '12 at 09:52
  • 1
    Server-side encryption then, to protect against attackers with physical access when the storage device is not in use? Ok. – Gilles 'SO- stop being evil' Oct 11 '12 at 09:57
  • @Gilles Precisely that, thanks for the better wording – Tobias Kienzler Oct 11 '12 at 10:06

2 Answers2

1

I'm seeing a sketch of a solution using Samba "logon scripts" - client-side code that runs after a samba login - but a complete solution needs to complete the sketch with details. Also related are "preexec scripts" - server-side code that runs during a samba login.

Referencing the smb.conf man page

logon script (G)

This parameter specifies the batch file (.bat) or NT command file (.cmd) to be downloaded and run on a machine when a user successfully logs in. The file must contain the DOS style CR/LF line endings. Using a DOS-style editor to create the file is recommended.

The script must be a relative path to the [netlogon] service. If the [netlogon] service specifies a path of /usr/local/samba/netlogon, and logon script = STARTUP.BAT, then the file that will be downloaded is:

/usr/local/samba/netlogon/STARTUP.BAT

The contents of the batch file are entirely your choice. A suggested command would be to add NET TIME \SERVER /SET /YES, to force every machine to synchronize clocks with the same time server. Another use would be to add NET USE U: \SERVER\UTILS for commonly used utilities, or

NET USE Q: \\SERVER\ISO9001_QA

for example.

Note that it is particularly important not to allow write access to the [netlogon] share, or to grant users write permission on the batch files in a secure environment, as this would allow the batch files to be arbitrarily modified and security to be breached.

This option takes the standard substitutions, allowing you to have separate logon scripts for each user or machine.

and also

preexec (S)

This option specifies a command to be run whenever the service is connected to. It takes the usual substitutions.

An interesting example is to send the users a welcome message every time they log in. Maybe a message of the day? Here is an example:

preexec = csh -c 'echo \"Welcome to %S!\" | /usr/local/samba/bin/smbclient -M %m -I %I' &

In your case, though, you really want logon scripts (unencrypted form is mounted on the client), so a solution sketch might involve:

  1. ensure that each computer has a EncFS equivalent installed
  2. write a logon script (.bat format) that calls encfs on the client and prompts the user for logon. The encfs command thus mounts the unencrypted form locally, with the remote store remaining encrypted.

  3. configure smb.conf so that the relevant users run the logon script. e.g. something like

    logon script = runencfs.bat

  4. For bonus points, your logon script might automate / prompt installation of Encfs (from the samba share) and only run the mount if it's installed!

Client-side scripts, though, are bound to give you headaches because of the cmd language, ensuring installation of encfs, and working around windows gotchas, like Windows 8.1 and up not running the logon scripts till five minutes later unless otherwise configured.

madumlao
  • 1,686
  • 10
  • 8
0

If your concern is the security of data at rest you could look for an encryption solution on the NAS instead (FreeNAS and Synology do this). Upon boot you need to enter a key to open the volume but after that, it works just like an unencrypted share so no client side configuration required.

If, on the other hand, you are concern about the data being taken from the server while it is running, having a client side encryption would solve your problem. Something like EncFS or Cryptomator could be the simplest solutions for your problem?

Or maybe I misunderstood the problem?

Pedro
  • 1,821
  • 12
  • 23